Is Roof Replacement Necessary? (Options, Pros & Cons)

Not sure if you need a roof replacement? In this guide, we'll explore the pros, cons and your option for getting a new roof.
Author picture

To provide you with the most accurate, up-to-date guides and cost figures, we gather information from a variety of local licensed contractors, pricing databases, and industry experts. Learn more.

Author picture

Reviewed by JC Sanjuan — General and roofing contractor with over a decade of experience in residential and commercial construction. He specializes in project management, quality workmanship, client satisfaction, and solving roofing challenges.

Linkedin Profile

Deciding whether roof replacement is necessary involves considering several factors, including the age of your roof, its current condition, and the extent of any damage. Let’s explore the options, along with the pros and cons of roof replacement.

Options Before Replacement


Minor damages like leaks, missing shingles, or small areas of wear can often be repaired, extending the life of your roof without the need for a full replacement.

Partial Replacement

If damage is localized to one area, a partial replacement might be sufficient. This can save money and time while addressing the problem.


Instead of removing the existing roof, new shingles are placed over the old ones. This is not always recommended due to weight issues and can mask underlying problems.

Pros of Roof Replacement

new roof replacement showing black asphalt architectural shingles
roof replacement done by contractor roofguides


A new roof can provide decades of protection, typically anywhere from 20 to 50 years or more, depending on the material.

Increased Home Value

A new roof can enhance your home’s curb appeal and potentially increase its resale value.

Energy Efficiency

Modern roofing materials are more energy-efficient, helping to keep your home cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter, which can lower energy bills.


Replacing an old, damaged roof can prevent health hazards like mold and mildew and protect your home from water damage and collapse.

Cons of Roof Replacement


The biggest drawback is the expense. A complete roof replacement can be costly, depending on the size of your roof and the materials chosen.


The process can take several days to complete, which might be inconvenient.


Removing the old roof materials can add to the project cost and environmental impact.

When to Consider Replacement


If your roof is nearing the end of its expected lifespan (20-25 years for asphalt shingles, for example), replacement might be more cost-effective than ongoing repairs.

Extensive Damage

For widespread damage or when repairs are no longer feasible or cost-effective, replacement is necessary.

Major Renovations

If you’re planning significant home renovations, it might be the right time to consider replacing the roof to match your home’s new aesthetic.


The decision to replace a roof should be based on a thorough inspection and consideration of your long-term plans for the home. If your roof is relatively new or the damage is minor, repairs or partial replacement might be sufficient. However, for older roofs or those with significant damage, replacement offers the benefits of safety, efficiency, and enhanced home value. Always consult with a professional roofing contractor to assess your specific situation and explore all your options before making a decision.

author avatar
Whether you need a repair or a complete replacement, we've got you covered. Our easy-to-understand guides on roofing and costs from experts will help you make the best decisions for your roofing project.
Content Overview
Related Articles
roofguide logo

We’re committed to providing you with the most accurate and up-to-date information to make informed decisions about your home improvement projects. Our research process is thorough, combining local contractor insights, permit data analysis, and building code reviews to ensure our guides reflect real-world costs and comply with the latest standards. We also stay on top of industry trends and best practices by consulting with experts. By factoring in both material and labor costs, we give you a complete picture of what your roof replacement might cost.

Find a Pro Near Me:

Roofing Contractor Talking to Homeowner Should I Home During A Roof Replacement
Look Up Pro Location
Use Shift+Tab to go back