Casselberry, FL Roof Replacement Costs (2024)

Median roof replacement costs in Casselberry range between $14,070 and $56,239 depending on factors like your roof’s size, pitch, and material.
Author picture

To provide you with the most accurate, up-to-date guides and cost figures, we gather information from a variety of local licensed contractors, pricing databases, and industry experts. Learn more.

Author picture

Reviewed by JC Sanjuan — General and roofing contractor with over a decade of experience in residential and commercial construction. He specializes in project management, quality workmanship, client satisfaction, and solving roofing challenges.

Linkedin Profile
roofguide logo
Why can you trust us?
To provide you with the most accurate and up-to-date cost figures, we gather information from a variety of pricing databases, local licensed contractors, and industry experts.

 


Key takeaways

Roof replacement costs in Casselberry range between $14,070 and $56,239 depending on factors like your roof’s size, pitch, and material. For a typical 2,000 square foot asphalt shingle roof is around $14,070. This translates to about $7.04 per square foot.

Typical asphalt shingle roof in Casselberry Florida | Source Zillow
Typical asphalt shingle roof in Casselberry Florida | Source Zillow

For such a roof, you’ll need approximately 31.25 roofing squares (100 square feet of roofing material), costing around $450.24 per square.

If you’re considering metal, a metal roof will cost around $36,182, or roughly $18.09 per square foot for the same size home.

Installing a metal roof over your existing asphalt shingle roof can initially save you about $1.50 per square foot, or around $3,000. However, most of the time, it’s best to remove the old roof. That way, you have peace of mind that the roof decking has no damaged wood and is solid for the new metal roof, ultimately protecting your investment for years to come.

Here is a table with Casselberry median roof replacement costs* for common roofing materials:

Roofing
Material
Median
Total Cost
Median Price
per Sq. Ft.
Median Price
per Roof Square
Asphalt Shingles $14,070 $7.04 $450.24
Metal $36,182 $18.09 $1,200.02
Concrete Tile $56,239 $28.12 $1,320.02
Mineral Roll  Roof $16,254 $8.13 $550.01
Slate $56,104 $28.05 $1,500.02
Wood Shake $42,760 $21.38 $1,300.02
Synthetic $52,464 $26.23 $1,650.03
Solar – Tesla Tiles $142,617 $71.31 $4,300.07
TPO – Flat Roof $33,986 $16.99 $1,150.02
Gravel $36,941 $18.47 $1,250.02
Copper $67,407 $33.70 $2,150.03

*Typically for a simple 2,000 square foot home with a medium roof pitch (5 : 12). Pricing will vary depending on your home’s unique conditions. When estimating your home’s size, remember to factor in the area under your roof, including garages, porches, and other spaces, not just the livable or conditioned areas.

Roof replacement costs in Casselberry can vary between neighborhoods. The presence of a Homeowners Association (HOA) in Casselberry neighborhoods like Fern Park, Deer Run, or Sterling Park can impact the cost of a roof replacement. This is due to potential HOA restrictions on roofing materials, colors, styles, and even the contractors allowed to work in the neighborhood.

Remember: The final cost of your roof replacement or repair will also depend on your roof’s size, pitch, the material of choice, design, complexity, need for additional repairs.

Use our roofing calculator below to get a closer estimate.

Quick Cost Calculator

Roofing Calculator

Sq. Ft.
Sq. Ft.
Ft.
Eave Stick Out, Ft= Feet.
Choose Roof Type.
Select Roof Pitch.

Results

1 Square = 100 Square Feet.
10%
0%20%
Select 10% for gable roofs and 12%-15% for hip roofs.
$
Input dollar amount per roof square.



In this guide, we’ll explore:

Without further ado, let’s get started!

Roof Replacement Costs by Material

Here are the most popular roofing options Casselberry including pros, cons, lifespans, and full roof replacement average costs per square foot (including material and labor):

Asphalt Shingles

shingles flat polymeric roof tiles background close up view

Asphalt shingles are the most popular residential roofing choice in Casselberry, valued for their affordability, diverse color/style selection, and straightforward installation. However, they typically last 15-30 years, making them shorter-lived compared to some alternatives. They’re also more vulnerable to storm damage and rank lower in environmental friendliness due to their manufacturing and disposal impact.

Estimated asphalt shingles roof replacement costs* in Casselberry, FL per home size:

Home Size Lower-End Mid-Range Higher-End
1,250 $7,913 $8,800 $11,875
1,500 $9,495 $10,560 $14,250
1,750 $11,078 $12,320 $16,625
2,000 $12,660 $14,080 $19,000
2,250 $14,243 $15,840 $21,375
2,500 $9,495 $17,600 $23,750
2,750 $17,408 $19,360 $26,125
3,000 $18,990 $21,120 $28,500

*Pricing will vary depending on your home’s unique conditions. Numbers based on total square footage of home under the roof, including garages, sheds, de-attached structures, etc. with a medium roof pitch (5 : 12).

Metal Roofing

ribbed metal roof under blue skies

Metal roofing is gaining popularity with its remarkable durability (40-70 years), energy efficiency, weather resistance, and the increasing use of recycled content. Its drawbacks include a higher upfront cost, potential noise during heavy rain, and possible denting from severe hail.

Estimated metal roof replacement costs* in Casselberry, FL per home size:

Home Size Lower-End Mid-Range Higher-End
1,250 $20,350 $22,613 $30,525
1,500 $24,420 $27,135 $36,630
1,750 $28,490 $31,658 $42,735
2,000 $32,560 $36,180 $48,840
2,250 $36,630 $40,703 $54,945
2,500 $24,420 $45,225 $61,050
2,750 $44,770 $49,748 $67,155
3,000 $48,840 $54,270 $73,260

*Pricing will vary depending on your home’s unique conditions. Numbers based on total square footage of home under the roof, including garages, sheds, de-attached structures, etc. with a medium roof pitch (5 : 12).

Tile Roofing

Terracotta colored roof tiles close up

Tile roofing offers unparalleled beauty and exceptional longevity (50+ years), with excellent fire and rot resistance, making it ideal for hot climates. However, the high cost, hefty weight requiring specialized installation, and the potential for individual tiles to crack are important considerations.

Estimated concrete tile roof replacement costs* in Casselberry, FL per home size:

Home Size Lower-End Mid-Range Higher-End
1,250 $31,638 $35,150 $47,450
1,500 $37,965 $42,180 $56,940
1,750 $44,293 $49,210 $66,430
2,000 $50,620 $56,240 $75,920
2,250 $56,948 $63,270 $85,410
2,500 $37,965 $70,300 $94,900
2,750 $69,603 $77,330 $104,390
3,000 $75,930 $84,360 $113,880

*Pricing will vary depending on your home’s unique conditions. Numbers based on total square footage of home under the roof, including garages, sheds, de-attached structures, etc. with a medium roof pitch (5 : 12).

Flat Roofing

Flat roof torched down installation

Flat roofing, generally associated with commercial buildings, also finds use in some residential contexts. It’s often more affordable than pitched roof options, enables rooftop decks/gardens, and offers variety with materials like TPO, EPDM, and modified bitumen, each with its own advantages.

The downsides include the need for regular maintenance, a higher risk of leaks if not properly installed, and a less traditional residential aesthetic.

Estimated flat rolled roof (modified bitumen, aka “granule mineral surface”) replacement costs* in Casselberry, FL per home size:

Home Size Lower-End Mid-Range Higher-End
1,250 $9,138 $10,163 $13,713
1,500 $10,965 $12,195 $16,455
1,750 $12,793 $14,228 $19,198
2,000 $14,620 $16,260 $21,940
2,250 $16,448 $18,293 $24,683
2,500 $10,965 $20,325 $27,425
2,750 $20,103 $22,358 $30,168
3,000 $21,930 $24,390 $32,910

*Pricing will vary depending on your home’s unique conditions. Numbers based on total square footage of home under the roof, including garages, sheds, de-attached structures, etc. with a low roof pitch (1 : 12).

Read: What’s the Best Material for a Flat Roof?

Slate

A modern house featuring a sleek slate roof with a newly installed skylight showcasing both style and functionality

Slate roofs can last over a century with minimal maintenance. They are highly durable and are fire-resistant. They can add timeless elegance to the right style home. A drawback is that slate tile can also break if not handled carefully. Slate roofs are common in the northern regions of the country.

Avg. Cost: $25.25 to $37.87 per sq. ft.
Lifespan: 60-100+ years

Built-up, Gravel roofs

Close up view of a multi layer built up roof system on a commercial building

A built-up gravel roof is a type of flat roofing system that is made up of multiple layers of materials. The layers typically include a base layer, multiple layers of bitumen (asphalt or coal tar), and a top layer of gravel or another protective material. The layers are bonded together to create a durable and waterproof surface. Built-up roofs are commonly used on commercial and industrial buildings, but can also be used on residential homes. You can find still find them in some older homes but because of the price, some homeowners end up tapering their roofs (if very flat) and opting for roll roofing.

Avg. Cost: $16.62 to $24.94 per sq. ft.
Lifespan: 15-20 years

Wood Shake

natural woodshake

Wood shake roofs are made from split logs and are popular for their rustic look and natural beauty. They are durable and resistant to wind and hail but require regular maintenance to prevent rot, mold, and insect damage. They are an energy-efficient, renewable and sustainable option. Wood shakes are not very common .

Avg. cost: $19.24 to $28.86 per sq. ft.
Lifespan: 20-30 years

Synthetic roofs

Collage photo showcasing a variety of synthetic roofing materials including synthetic slate cedar shakes and clay tiles to highlight the range of choices available

Synthetic roofs are roofing materials that mimic natural materials like wood, slate, or clay tiles. They are made of plastic, rubber, or polymer and offer several advantages over traditional materials. Synthetic roofs are lightweight, durable, weather-resistant, and environmentally friendly. They are also easier to install and require less maintenance. Synthetic roofs are not as common either. However, they’ve gained some traction in the last few years.

Avg. cost: $23.61 to $35.41 per sq. ft.
Lifespan: 40-50 years

Solar roofs

Tesla Solar Glass Roof

Solar roofs generate electricity from sunlight, thus reducing energy costs. For instance, Tesla offers roof tiles that blend seamlessly and are highly durable in all weather conditions including hail. The main drawback is the high initial cost.

Avg. Cost: $64.18 to $96.27 per sq. ft.
Lifespan: 25-30 years

Copper

Copper Roof

Copper roofs are made of copper sheets that are durable and long-lasting. They’re popular in historical buildings and known for their aesthetic appeal. Over time, copper roofs develop a green patina, which many people consider beautiful. They are one of the most expensive roofs in the market. Despite being expensive, they’re a worthwhile investment because of durability and energy efficiency.

Avg. Cost: $30.33 to $45.50 per sq. ft.
Lifespan: 60-100 years

Roof Replacement Cost Factors

The total cost of your roof replacement is dictated by the following:

The size of your roof

The larger your roof, the more materials and labor are needed, generally making it more expensive to replace. Roofers calculate these costs by squares, which is a 10-foot by 10-foot area. The total squares required and the complexity of your roof design will determine the overall cost.

Florida home with a hip roof shape showing with blue skies and green frontyard on a sunny day

A typical 1,750 square-foot home with an asphalt shingle gable-hip roof and a medium pitch has roughly 26 squares— which takes into account the roof’s pitch, overhangs, and material waste factor.  Typically in neighborhoods such as Deer Run, expect generally higher prices due to larger homes and potential HOA restrictions.

The following table shows approximately the number of squares for different home sizes:

Home Size (Square Feet) Approx. Roof Squares
1,000 16
1,250 19
1,500 23
1,750 26
2,000 30
2,250 33
2,500 36
2,750 40
3,000 43

Roof material

The type of material you choose affects the cost of your roof replacement. The cost of different roofing materials varies based on their prices and installation costs.

Asphalt shingles, the most popular material, are generally less expensive than metal or tile roofing. However, metal and tile roofs tend to last longer and require less maintenance than asphalt shingles. In the next section, we’ll go over each material’s pros, cons, and lifespans.

Roof pitch

Steep blue tile roof shown in clear skies

Expect to pay more if your house has a steep roof. Typically, a simple roof pitch ranges from 2:12 to 6:12. Most homes have roofs with a medium pitch between 4:12 and 5:12. The higher the pitch, the higher the inclination, the harder it is to work on. Roofs above 6:12 are more challenging— labor production slows down, and more safety measures must be taken.

roof pitch table

A higher pitch also means more roofing material will be needed. For example, a 2,000 square foot with a 2:12 pitch will need roughly 2,028 square feet of material, while a 8:12 will need 2,404 square feet, or an extra 376 square feet.

Home Size (SF) Roof Pitch Pitch Factor Roof Size (SF)
2,000 1 : 12 1.004 2,008
2,000 2 : 12 1.014 2,028
2,000 3 : 12 1.031 2,062
2,000 4 : 12 1.054 2,108
2,000 5 : 12 1.083 2,166
2,000 6 : 12 1.118 2,236
2,000 7 : 12 1.158 2,316
2,000 8 : 12 1.202 2,404
2,000 9 : 12 1.25 2,500
2,000 10 : 12 1.302 2,604
2,000 11 : 12 1.357 2,714
2,000 12 : 12 1.414 2,828

Depending on the roof size, you can expect to pay an extra $1,000 to $2,500 for each pitch over 6:12.

Roof access, design, and features

Big Brick Home with Seamless Gutters Wide Angle Perspective
CreditJames Brey

Your roof design and access also have an impact on the total cost. If your home has the following conditions, your roof replacement cost will be higher:

  • Two-story house or higher
  • Roof sections with different levels
  • Hip roofs: Higher material waste
  • Dormers, chimneys and skylights
  • Trees and shrubs around the perimeter walls of your roof
  • Homes with pools without screen enclosures
  • Dumpster not being able to be near the roof

These mainly affect labor, material delivery, old roof removal and disposal fees. Roofers need to budget and charge more for these conditions. For example, in Casselberry, popular neighborhoods such as Deer Run have different roof styles and materials

Need for additional repairs and work

If your home is older than 30 year, it will most likely require more extensive repairs than a newer house. Issues such as wood damage, wall flashing problems, inadequate ventilation and insulation are very common .

Older roofs also tend to have several layers of felt or underlayment, impacting removal, cleaning, and dumping costs as well. All these repairs and extras can add up quickly to the total cost of your roof replacement.

Casselberry local market

Labor costs for roof replacement can vary significantly based on your location. Homeowners in areas with a high cost of living should expect to pay more for labor. Additionally, the prevalence of specific roof types in a region can impact labor costs – in areas where certain styles are common, experienced contractors are more readily available, potentially leading to lower prices.

For example, in Casselberry, roof replacement costs tend to be more affordable compared to neighboring cities like Winter Park and Maitland.

Permitting Roofing requirements

Various states and cities have different roofing requirements. For instance, here in Florida, given our susceptibility to hurricanes, roofing materials and installation methods must meet specific wind resistance standards. This means using materials and techniques that can withstand high wind speeds.

In the northeast of the country different installation are required for a roofing system that is durable and resistant to heavy snowstorms. These different requirements impact the cost of roof replacements.

Choosing the Right Roofing Material

Choosing the best roofing material for your home is an important decision. While metal roofs offer great benefits, several factors will determine the ideal choice for you. These include local roofing requirements, your budget, the quality of the material, and how well it complements your home’s architectural style.

Recommendations

In Florida, the weather can be harsh with intense sun and temperature, heavy rains, humidity and occasional hurricanes. That’s why it’s best to choose a roofing system that will withstand these conditions.

Roof anatomy by Certainteed

Roof covering materials like metal, tile, or high-quality asphalt shingles from top brands such as GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning are excellent choices.

Choosing energy-efficient options can keep your home cooler and reduce air conditioning costs. Light-colored tiles, reflective metal roofing, or Energy Star ‘cool’ shingles are great to combat the temperature and energy bills.

Roof Replacement vs. Repair

You don’t always need to replace your entire roof if you notice issues like leaks or damaged flashing. You can opt for repairs if the roof is in good condition.

Here are the average roof repair costs in Casselberry, FL:

Roof Repair Service Avg. Cost per Item
Full Roof Inspection $150 – $450
Shingle Roof Repair – Small Patch $250 – $275
Shingle Roof Repair, Medium Size $750 – $2,500+
Tile Roof Repairs, Small to Medium $750 – $7,500+
Flat Roof Repairs, Small to Medium $750 – $3,000+
TPO Roof Repairs, Small to Medium $1,000 – $7,500+
Metal Roof Repairs – Small To Medium $725 – $6,000+
Skylight – Small Repairs $250 – $750+
Skylight Replacements 2′ X 2′ $750 – $1,500+
Wall Flashing Repairs (per linear ft.) Starting at $850*
Ridge Vent Repair Or Replacement Starting at $750*
Roof & Gutter Clean Up Starting at $250*
Fascia Replacement (per linear ft.) Starting at $900*
Soffit Replacement (per linear ft.) Starting at $150* per linear foot

*Typically for a simple 2,000 square foot home. Pricing will vary depending on your home’s conditions.

A local roofing contractor can take a closer look at your roof and recommend if it would be best to repair or fully replace it.

Full vs. Partial Roof Replacement

If only a section of your roof needs work, you may be better off with a partial replacement. You’ll likely pay less to replace a portion than your whole roof. However, even though partial replacement may cost less upfront, it could lead to mismatches and future repairs, and you still will need a permit. Full replacement offers long-term savings, a consistent appearance, and increased home value. Plus, it comes with a warranty.

Replace a Roof Yourself vs. Hiring a Pro

If you’re handy and experienced with construction projects, replacing your own roof could save you big bucks, particularly if you’re on a tight budget. Doing it yourself can save on labor and markup costs.

Roofers replacing roof

For instance, on labor alone, you could save 30% of the total cost. So, on a $10,000 roof replacement, that’s a saving of $3,000. Also, not including supervision costs, overhead, and markups – which add up to another 25%, or $2,500 – means your total savings could be as much as $5,500.

But DIY roofing has its challenges.

Roofing requires specific skills for proper removal and installation. In Florida, where building codes and inspections are among the strictest, not meeting standards can lead to costly mistakes.

roof flashing damaged found in chimney wall
Credit RoofGuides

Us roofers often find hidden damages that can be expensive and time-consuming to fix, and this process might take even longer for a non-professional. Plus, roofing is inherently dangerous, particularly with complex roofs, so for safety and quality, it might be wiser to hire an experienced roofer.

Finally, unless you’re a licensed roofing contractor, your insurance company likely won’t cover the costs of roof repairs or replacement. Hiring a contractor comes with a warranty, providing peace of mind, a benefit you miss out on when doing the work yourself.

Paying for Your Roof Replacement

Dollar bills and credit cards as form of payment

When funding roof repairs or a full replacement, homeowners have a few options to consider. Each option has its own advantages and is suitable for different financial situations.

Using your savings is the most direct approach. It’s interest-free and doesn’t involve any borrowing. If you have the necessary funds set aside, this option can be the simplest and most cost-effective. However, if this is not the case, don’t worry; other great options exist.

Here are some of the best ways to finance your roofing project:

Roofing company financing

Many roofing companies offer financing plans for their projects. These can be convenient as they often come with quick approval and may have special terms like deferred payments or lower interest rates for a period.

Make sure to thoroughly understand the terms and conditions before agreeing.

Home equity loan or line of credit (HELOC)

A home equity loan or line of credit can be an excellent choice for homeowners with equity in their property. These options often come with lower interest rates than other types of loans. They can provide a substantial amount of money. However, it’s important to remember that these loans use your home as collateral.

Personal loan

Personal loans from banks or credit unions are another route. These loans are usually unsecured, and their approval, as well as the interest rate, largely depends on your credit score. They can be a quick way to access funds, especially if you have a good credit history.

Using credit cards

For more minor roof repairs, credit cards can be a handy option. This route is best if you can pay off the balance quickly to avoid accruing high interest.

Government loans or grants

See if you are eligible for local and federal home improvement grants to help cover your roofing costs. Organizations like the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) assist qualified homeowners in taking advantage of such savings. This could be a low-interest loan or even free money you don’t have to pay back.

Insurance claims

Filing a claim can be a viable option if your roof damage is the result of an event covered by your homeowner’s insurance, like a storm or natural disaster. Insurance may cover a significant portion of the repair or replacement costs.

Tips to Save on Your Roof Replacement

Get multiple quotes from reputable local roofing contractors to find the best deal. Remember, the cheapest doesn’t always mean the best.

If possible, schedule your roof replacement during late fall or winter when it’s the off-season. , the busiest months for roofers are spring and summer.

Ask roofers about special discounts for referrals, veterans, or seniors they might offer. Look for deals during off-peak seasons, check ads, consider group discounts with neighbors, and follow roofing companies on social media.

Signs You Need Roof Work Done

Roof damage can come from many sources — storms, trees, animals, etc. Here are the most common roof damages homeowners experience :

Roof leaks

ceiling water damage stain from flat roof leak

If you notice water stains on your ceiling, especially after a rainstorm, your roof could be leaking.

Missing or damaged shingles

badly damaged roof with missing shingles in need of repair

Look for shingles that are cracked, bent, or missing entirely. This can lead to leaks and further damage.

Sagging

sagging roof roofguides

A droopy, sagging roof is a sign that your roof is in trouble. It might mean there’s trapped moisture or rotting boards.

Moss and algae growth

Green Moss And Algae On Slate Roof Tiles

While it might look just cosmetic, moss and algae can trap moisture and damage the roof structure.

Granules in the gutters

full rain gutter on roof

If your shingles are shedding granules, which look like coarse, black sand, they might be nearing the end of their life.​

Sunlight through the roof boards

hole in attic

If you can see light coming through your roof in the attic, that means water can get through as well.​

High energy bills

no or poor insulation in attic

Unexpected increases in your heating or cooling costs might be due to poor roof insulation, letting air escape.

Curled shingle edges

close up on damaged asphalt shingles

Shingles that are curling at the edges are a sign of wear and possible leaks.

Chimney flashing damage

wall flashing issues in roofs

If the flashing around your chimney is damaged or missing, it can lead to leaks in the roof.

Should I Repair or Get a New Roof?

Repair your roof if:

Roof with missing and damaged asphalt shingles

  • If you notice just a few missing shingles, small leaks, or minor wear and tear, repairs might suffice.
  • When the issue is confined to a small area, repairs can often fix the problem without the need for a full replacement.
  • If your budget is tight and the damage is not extensive, repair is a practical option.

Get a full roof replacement if:

complete roof damage need for full roof replacement
  • If there’s significant damage across the roof, like widespread leaks and there are major structural issues like wood decking or trusses.
  • When a roof reaches the end of its expected lifespan and shows signs of wear, replacing will prevent future problems.

Inspect your roof

Inspector Showing How To Find Roof Leaks in an Attic of a Single Family Home for Roof Leaks
  • At least once a year, especially after harsh weather seasons.
  • After severe weather, like hurricanes or hailstorms, an inspection can identify damage that isn’t immediately obvious.
  • If your roof is nearing or has passed its expected lifespan (usually 20-25 years for asphalt shingles), an inspection is wise.

Frequently Asked Questions

FAQ's

Does homeowners insurance cover roof?

What does a new roof include?

How long does it take to replace a roof?

How do you maintain your roof?

What's the difference between a contract and a quote?

 


 

author avatar
RoofGuides
Whether you need a repair or a complete replacement, we've got you covered. Our easy-to-understand guides on roofing and costs from experts will help you make the best decisions for your roofing project.
Related Articles
roofguide logo

We’re committed to providing you with the most accurate and up-to-date information to make informed decisions about your home improvement projects. Our research process is thorough, combining local contractor insights, permit data analysis, and building code reviews to ensure our guides reflect real-world costs and comply with the latest standards. We also stay on top of industry trends and best practices by consulting with experts. By factoring in both material and labor costs, we give you a complete picture of what your roof replacement might cost.

Find a Pro Near Me:

Roofing Contractor Talking to Homeowner Should I Home During A Roof Replacement
Look Up Pro Location
Use Shift+Tab to go back